What player mode did you use when adding the player set up layers?
Based on your description, it sounds like you need to use mode 9 or 10 when adding the player. You are probably leaving it on mode 1.
See this webpage that has a description of how all of the modes work. This page has 7 different videos that cover how all of the player alignment modes work, plug the team mode and the logo modes.
Damon Bell
